Children’s stories are usually about simplicity, vibrant scenes, and valuable lessons. However, a notable shift is underway. Traditionally, these narratives focused on instilling good attributes and teaching virtues like truthfulness, respect, and helpfulness simply and engagingly. However, as the landscape evolves, Molly Arbuthnott, Scottish children’s book author and teacher, brings forth a thought-provoking perspective.
The Shift in Children’s Stories: From Traditional to “Woke”
Molly draws from her seven years of teaching experience to highlight a noticeable shift in the children’s infotainment industry. She raises an important concern about the inclusion of what some term as “woke” elements in modern children’s stories. This shift has triggered apprehensions among parents, who fear that these mature concepts might be too intricate for young minds, potentially hindering the enjoyable learning experience that stories should provide.
Molly Arbuthnott’s Perspective: A Call for Authenticity
Molly contends that in the pursuit of being woke and attempting to cater to a broad audience, the content risks losing its genuine connection with its primary viewers – children. She challenges the one-size-fits-all approach, bringing attention to the potential downside of diluting stories to conform to widely accepted ideals.
“I believe that the story industry (particularly for children) has become quite woke, and in being woke and trying to appeal to everyone, it has gradually appealed to no one and has less to offer,” Molly notes.
The Desire for Honest Narratives
Arbuthnott is an advocate for honest and true stories, encouraging a return to authenticity, where stories unfold naturally without adhering to a specific ideological framework. This challenges industry norms, sparking a conversation about balancing social responsibility with relatable storytelling.
Finding the Middle Ground: Social Awareness and Age-Appropriate Content
It’s important to clarify that diverging from the trend doesn’t mean rejecting inclusivity or avoiding important social issues. Molly wants a more nuanced approach. Stories should not be overloaded with ideas that are not age appropriate for children.
Storytelling plays a role in shaping young minds.
Molly Arbuthnott’s Approach: Relatable Stories for Kids
Molly has authored several popular books, under the umbrella of the Oscar and Friends series. She crafts a tale that strikes a balance between social awareness and relatability. Through the adventures of Oscar, she subtly introduces important concepts without imposing strong messages. Oscar the Ferry Cat (ISBN: 978-1-59079-566-8; $16.99 USD) is a delightful children’s book series created by Molly and published by SelectBooks, Inc., it is set to be released in the US on May 14, 2024. Rose Leslie, who played Ygritte on the hit HBO series, Game of Thrones, wrote of it, “Such a delightful read. Long may Oscar and his adventures continue!”
The series revolves around the character Oscar, a ferry cat, and his adventures with various friends. Each book in the series takes young readers on a journey filled with fun, friendship, and valuable life lessons.
“I am trying to break this trend by sharing honest and true stories that don’t try to conform to any right or wrong way of doing things. They just are, as I try my best to live,” says Molly.
Contributing to a Broader Dialogue
As discussions on children’s storytelling continue, voices like Molly’s become crucial. They contribute to a broader dialogue about the delicate balance between social consciousness and the timeless magic of genuine narratives. The industry must balance reflecting diverse childhood experiences with preserving the authenticity that makes storytelling cherished.
Sarah Ferguson, Duchess of York has created a beautiful video production of her reading from Oscar the Ferry Cat for her YouTube channel. It can be viewed here.